The Milwaukee Brewers have made one of their most intriguing roster moves of the season, selecting the contract of Anthony Seigler, a former New York Yankees first-rounder, whose journey from high school phenom to big-league debutant has been anything but linear. Seigler’s call-up is more than a feel-good story. This is a strategic move that could have ripple effects on the Brewers’ playoff push and roster flexibility.
Brewers Call Up Anthony Seigler
A Renaissance for a Forgotten Prospect
Seigler, 26, arrived in Milwaukee on a minor league deal this offseason after several injury-plagued and underwhelming years in the Yankees’ system. At Triple-A Nashville, he has rewritten his narrative, slashing .278/.416/.469 with 7 home runs, 35 RBI, 43 runs, and 20 stolen bases in 62 games. His eye at the plate is elite, with an 18.4 percent walk rate and a .416 OBP, which stands out in today’s game.
We’ve made the following roster moves pic.twitter.com/msjqsXabEt
— Milwaukee Brewers (@Brewers) July 1, 2025
Versatility is the Name of the Game
What sets Seigler apart is his positional versatility. Though drafted as a switch-hitting, switch-throwing catcher, Seigler has logged significant time at catcher, second base, and third base this season. While Brice Turang has second base locked down and the left side of the infield has stabilized, Seigler’s ability to catch and play infield gives manager Pat Murphy a true Swiss Army knife for late-game maneuvering or injury insurance.
Seigler’s defensive work behind the plate has drawn praise. He has shown the ability to control the running game and work with young arms. With Andruw Monasterio struggling at the plate, Seigler could immediately upgrade the bench as a utility infielder. His 20 steals in 23 attempts add a speed element rarely seen from a backup catcher or utility infielder.
The Roster Domino Effect
The Brewers designated outfielder Daz Cameron for assignment to make room for Seigler. More importantly, Seigler’s arrival could allow the team to rest William Contreras. Contreras has been playing through a finger injury and has seen his production dip. If Contreras hits the IL, Seigler could see meaningful innings behind the plate. Seigler has the potential to impact games both offensively and defensively.
What to Expect
Seigler’s offensive profile is unique for a backup catcher/utility man. He has a high OBP, sneaky power, and speed. He’s abandoned switch-hitting to focus exclusively on hitting left-handed, where he’s posted a .975 OPS against righties this season. If he gets regular at-bats, especially against right-handed pitching, he could provide a spark at the bottom of the lineup.
The Last Word
Anthony Seigler’s call-up is a testament to perseverance and adaptability. For the Brewers, it’s a low-risk, high-upside move. It bolsters their depth at a crucial point in the season. Whether he becomes a fan favorite or a key bench piece, Seigler’s versatility and on-base skills could quietly help Milwaukee maintain its edge in a tight NL Central race.
Main Photo Credit: © Dave Kallmann / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
The post Brewers Call Up Anthony Seigler from Triple-A Nashville: What It Means for the Crew appeared first on Last Word On Baseball.